Ten years since its introduction, does F1 need its superlicence points system? · RaceFans

Tomorrow will be 10 years to the day since the FIA confirmed the details of a new points system to determine who should be allowed to race in Formula 1.

The superlicence points system originally awarded points to drivers based only on their finishing positions in different categories beneath F1. Now extra points are awarded for participating in F1 practice sessions, avoiding penalties and more.

The threshold requirement of 40 points remains unchanged. Every aspiring F1 driver knows they must rack up those 40 points over three seasons in order to achieve their goal (the requirement to do so in consecutive seasons was temporarily relaxed due to the Covid-19 pandemic).

F1’s superlicence system has potentially prevented some drivers from racing in F1 when they could have done. AlphaTauri (now Racing Bulls) wanted to run IndyCar driver Colton Herta in 2023, but could not as he did not have sufficient superlicence points, despite being a multiple race-winner in one of the few single seater categories where car performance is close to that seen in F1.

A decade since its introduction, is F1’s superlicence points system performing a useful function for the series and for upcoming drivers?

The FIA F1 superlicence points system in 2025

Points are awarded for drivers’ finishing positions in these championships as follows:

Series1st2nd3rd4th5th6th7th8th9th10thTotal
FIA Formula 24040403020108643201
FIA Formula 3302520151297532128
FIA WEC (Hypercar)3024201612108642132
Japanese Super Formula302520151297532128
IndyCar40302010864321124
FIA Formula E30252010864321109
Formula Regional European Championship2520151075321088
Japanese Super GT5002016121075321076
IMSA Grand Touring Prototype2016121075321076
Formula Regional Middle East Championship1814121064321070
Formula Regional Americas Championship1814121064321070
Formula Regional Japanese Championship1814121064321070
Formula Regional Oceania Championship1814121064321070
Formula Regional Indian Championship1814121064321070
Deutsche Tourenwagen Masters642000000012
International Supercars Championship151210753210055
NASCAR Cup151210753210055
Indy Lights (now Indy Nxt)151210753210055
Euroformula Open151210753210055
Japanese Super Formula Lights151210753210055
National FIA Formula 4 Championships certified by the FIA12107532100040
Asian / ELMS / IMSA Le Mans Prototype 2 (LMP2)1086420000030
FIA WEC (LMGT3)12107532100040
F1 Academy1075310000026
Indy Pro 20001075310000026
GB3 Championship1075310000026
NASCAR National1075310000026
GT3 Championships registered as International Series642000000012
Japanese Super GT300642000000012
FIA Karting World Championships in senior category432100000010
FIA Karting Continental Championships in senior category32100000006
FIA Karting World Championships in junior category32100000006
FIA Karting Continental Championships in junior category21000000003

| Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

Points are only awarded if championships meet various criteria, including only visiting FIA-certified tracks and involving a minimum number of drivers. Drivers can only count points from two championships per year and no more than 12 points from karting series.

Three further points are awarded to the winner of the Formula Regional World Cup. Drivers can accumulate up to 10 points by participating in Formula 1 practice sessions and gain an additional two points by keeping a ‘clean sheet’ in any series where penalty points are issued for driving infractions.

For

Formula 1 is the top level of international motor racing and drivers need to show they are capable of handling powerful machines and following the rules of racing. Junior championships are the best way to do this and it makes sense to favour those whose rules and regulations are closest to F1’s.

No system is ever going to be perfect, and although F1’s superlicence points system is complicated, it largely does its job.

Against

The superlicence points system sets a higher bar for some drivers depending on what series they were able to race in, which may have less to do with their ability than what they can afford. F1’s top junior series have become even more expensive in recent years as all their races take place at grand prix weekends.

The points allocations for some series show the system is intended to favour FIA over non-FIA series, putting drivers from some regions, notably the USA, at a disadvantage.

I say

The past five years have revealed how cynical the superlicence points system is. When an IndyCar driver such as Colton Herta comes up short, no exceptions are made. When a wealthy driver in an FIA-sanctioned series needs a licence, suddenly the system is more malleable.

Any system which blocks a driver of Herta’s ability while waving in the likes of Nikita Mazepin can’t be taken seriously.

New F1 drivers should be required to take tests demonstrating they can drive the cars and understand the racing rules. The unnecessary, over-complicated and bureaucratic superlicence points system should be binned.

You say

When we asked our readers this question five years ago, many did not approve of superlicence points but a significant minority felt the system had merit. Five years on, have those views changed significantly?

Do you agree F1 should keep its superlicence points system?

  • No opinion (0%)
  • Strongly disagree (75%)
  • Slightly disagree (25%)
  • Neither agree nor disagree (0%)
  • Slightly agree (0%)
  • Strongly agree (0%)

Total Voters: 4

Loading ... Loading …

| Become a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

A RaceFans account is required in order to vote. If you do not have one, register an account here or read more about registering here. When this poll is closed the result will be displayed instead of the voting form.

Miss nothing from RaceFans

Get a daily email with all our latest stories – and nothing else. No marketing, no ads. Sign up here:

Debates and polls

Browse all debates and polls

Leave your comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *